Current Contests/Announcements

The story of the Orange Cake Click here to find out more.

Check out the NKOTB Book Tag Meme Here!

Having trouble leaving a comment? If you have trouble commenting then please click on the refresh button, this usually fixes the issue. I also use comment moderation for new commenters to the blog.

Monday, February 20, 2012

The Fault in Our Stars by John Green (Audio)

Posted by Irish in Review6 Comments

Publisher:  Brilliance Audio (Audio); Dutton Juvenile (Print)
Source: Publisher
Publication Date: 10 Jan 2012(Audio);  10 Jan 2012 (Print)
Series or Standalone: Standalone
ISBN: 1455869880 (Audio), 0525478817 (Hardcover)
Format: Audio
Audio Length:  8 discs (~10 hrs)
Narrator: Kate Rudd
John Green – Blog (YouTube Channel)
Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
First Line: My mother thought I was depressed.

They say that your first John Green book will be your favorite John Green book and the rest, while good, are just variations on a theme. If this is true, then my first John Green book will probably be my last John Green book. Despite the fact that The Fault in Our Stars was a cancer book I had high hopes for it as everyone of the blog reviews I read and most of the people I follow on Twitter seemed to love and adore this book. But for me it just didn’t work. To me the characters didn’t come across as teens…and more often than not the overly pretentious dialogue had me rolling my eyes in exasperation. 

I also found the story to be unnecessarily manipulative. Rather than emotions flowing naturally from the narrative I felt manipulated to feel certain things at certain points in time. It just made the whole thing seem so forced and kept taking me out of this story that was supposed to make me this big huge emotional mess. The situations just never really came across as real for me and the I saw the big twist coming long before it happened. 

I also didn’t like how the book started off in the present with Hazel narrating her life as things happened. Then towards the end things shifted from her going forward to her narration coming across as a flashback. Which again became a manipulative set up trying to force the reader to get all sad and filled with heartache before the big sad happened. If this book had a musical score some of these moments would have been filled with the slow build of dramatic violins playing just the right notes to touch those heart strings. There are ways to manipulate emotions without trying to beat people over the head with text that pretty much screams “this is how you are supposed to feel and I’ll do everything I can can as an author to make you feel it!” And I think that played a big part in how I just couldn’t care about any of the characters in this book. I do not like being forced into liking people. Even fictional ones.

Everyone I know seems to love and adore John Green books but the whole thing just left me feeling blah. The writing and story telling in this book weren’t all that spectacular and I never connected with any of the characters. If you want a book that deals with cancer and real teens then I would recommend reading Drums, Girls & Dangerous Pie by Jordan Sonnenblick (my review) instead. Now there is a book that is both raw and realistic. Never once did I feel as though my feeling were being manipulated. And never once did I ever doubt that the characters weren’t real teens. I don’t get the hype of John Green. I thought that after reading his newest and super celebrated book that I would get it. But I don’t. And I don’t think that I ever will.

About the narrator
About the only thing that I enjoyed about The Fault in Our Stars was the narrator, Kate Rudd. She took this blah story and made it so I didn’t want to tear my hair out by the end. I think it was because of the narrator that I managed to finish this one. She was really good with all the voices and actually managed to make Hazel sound like a teen despite the text which ages her so very much.

People who felt differently than I did

Radiant Reads – “This is the kind of book that makes you think about life and death and what kind of mark you want to leave on the world.”

Moonlight Reader – “A brilliant novel filled with heartache, love, hope, trust, friendship and loss. This book was filled with so many emotions; it made me cry, so much!”

Girls in the Stacks – “How does John Green create these complex characters with depth, soul and wisdom? I’m not sure, but I do believe this book is a modern day classic.”

Bookhouse Boy – “TFiOS is a classic love story but its more than that too, its funny and smart and there is adventure in it as well.”

6 Responses to “The Fault in Our Stars by John Green (Audio)”

  1. Chrisbookarama

    There is something about this book that keeps me from reading it. I think my fear is that I would feel like you did. I don’t like books that go out of their way to manipulate me and will avoid anything that smells of it. That’s probably why I stopped watching Grey’s Anatomy years ago.

  2. Tricia

    I felt the same way about Looking for Alaska. I too have been hesitant to read this book and you’ve definitely providedfood for thought. I loved Drums, Girls and Dangerous Pie though!

  3. YA Bibliophile

    Sad you didn’t like this one. I loved it! To each there own 🙂 I did just want to point out that the first line starts, “Late in the winter of my seventeenth year, my mother decided I was depressed….” so the whole book is Hazel looking back. The tense doesn’t change. 🙂

  4. Marg

    I literally did a double take when I saw your grade as I have only heard fantastic things about this book!

    I haven’t yet read John Green so it will be interesting to compare reactions to yours!